Gay History: The Twinkie Defense: Dan White, Harvey Milk and the Verdict That Enraged San Francisco

There are moments when a complicated historical event becomes reduced to a single memorable phrase.

For the trial of Dan White, that phrase was “the Twinkie defense.”

The popular version of the story is wonderfully absurd.

In November 1978, former San Francisco supervisor Dan White shot and killed Mayor George Moscone and fellow supervisor Harvey Milk. When White came to trial, so the story goes, his lawyers claimed that he had eaten so much junk food that he could not be held fully responsible for what he had done.

The jury believed it.

White escaped a murder conviction and was convicted instead of voluntary manslaughter.

Thus, according to legend, Twinkies got a double murderer off lightly.

It is a magnificent story.

It is also not quite true.

Twinkies really did enter the evidence at White’s trial, along with other junk food. But White’s lawyers did not argue that eating Twinkies caused him to murder Moscone and Milk.

The real defence was far more complicated—and arguably more disturbing.

Harvey Milk and a Changing San Francisco

By the late 1970s, San Francisco was undergoing enormous social and political change.

One of the most visible symbols of that transformation was Harvey Milk.

Milk had moved to San Francisco in 1972 and opened a camera shop in the Castro, the neighbourhood rapidly becoming the centre of the city’s growing gay community. He became increasingly involved in local politics and, after several unsuccessful campaigns, was elected to the San Francisco Board of Supervisors in 1977.

His election was historically significant.

Milk became one of the first openly gay elected officials in the United States and rapidly emerged as a national symbol of gay political participation.

He was outspoken, theatrical, humorous and politically astute.

Milk also understood something fundamental about gay politics: invisibility helped prejudice survive.

He therefore urged gay men and lesbians to come out—to families, friends, neighbours and colleagues. Once people realised that somebody they loved or respected was gay, he believed, it became considerably harder to regard homosexuals as some remote and threatening minority.

Milk’s politics inevitably made enemies.

The late 1970s were witnessing a powerful conservative backlash against gay rights. Anita Bryant’s “Save Our Children” campaign had successfully helped repeal gay-rights protections in Miami-Dade County, while California’s Proposition 6—the Briggs Initiative—attempted to prohibit gay men and lesbians, and potentially their supporters, from working in public schools.

Milk became one of the most prominent opponents of Proposition 6.

California voters defeated it in November 1978.

Less than three weeks later, Harvey Milk was dead.

Dan White

Dan White represented a very different San Francisco.

A former police officer and firefighter, White was elected to the Board of Supervisors at the same election that brought Milk into office.

Politically and personally, the two men were very different.

White represented a more socially conservative constituency and was frequently identified with the city’s traditional working- and middle-class communities. Milk represented the increasingly politically organised gay population of the Castro.

Their relationship was nevertheless more complicated than a simple gay-versus-conservative confrontation.

They sometimes cooperated politically and at other times clashed.

White was the only supervisor to vote against San Francisco’s landmark gay-rights ordinance in 1978.

By November that year, however, White had another problem.

Money.

The salary paid to supervisors was inadequate for his family’s financial needs, and on 10 November 1978 White resigned his seat.

Almost immediately, he regretted it.

White asked Mayor George Moscone to reappoint him.

Moscone initially appeared willing to do so, but opposition developed—including from Milk and other political figures—and Moscone ultimately decided not to return White to the Board.

White believed he had been betrayed.

On the morning of 27 November 1978, he went to City Hall.

And he carried a gun.

The Assassinations

White entered City Hall through a basement window rather than using the normal public entrance.

This detail would later become particularly troubling in light of the defence argument that White lacked the mental capacity necessary for premeditated murder.

White was carrying his loaded .38-calibre revolver and additional ammunition.

He went to Mayor Moscone’s office and asked to speak privately with him.

The conversation did not end peacefully.

White shot Moscone repeatedly, including shots to the head at close range.

He then left the mayor’s office.

He did not leave City Hall.

Instead, White proceeded to the area containing Harvey Milk’s office.

After speaking briefly with Milk, White shot him five times, including two close-range shots to the head.

Two of San Francisco’s most important political figures were dead.

White subsequently surrendered to police and confessed.

There was never any serious question about who killed George Moscone and Harvey Milk.

The question at White’s trial would instead become:

What crime had Dan White committed when he killed them?

Murder or Manslaughter?

White was charged with first-degree murder with special circumstances.

The stakes were enormous.

A conviction potentially exposed him to the death penalty.

His defence lawyers therefore attacked one of the essential components necessary for the most serious murder conviction: White’s mental ability to premeditate, deliberate and form the required malice.

California law at the time recognised the doctrine of diminished capacity.

It did not necessarily mean that a defendant was insane.

Instead, the defence could argue that mental impairment prevented the accused from forming the particular mental state required for a specific crime.

White’s lawyers presented evidence portraying him as a profoundly troubled man who had deteriorated psychologically before the killings.

Psychiatrists testified about depression.

His behaviour had changed.

His appearance had changed.

His relationships had changed.

And then somebody mentioned his diet.

Enter the Twinkie.

Here Comes the Twinkie

White had previously been intensely concerned with fitness.

According to testimony, this health-conscious former firefighter had begun behaving differently as his psychological condition deteriorated.

Among those changes was his diet.

Instead of his previous healthy eating habits, White was consuming sugary drinks and junk food.

Including Twinkies.

Psychiatrist Dr Martin Blinder discussed this change while giving evidence about White’s mental state.

And this is where history and mythology parted company.

The defence was not simply arguing:

Dan ate Twinkies.
Twinkies altered Dan’s brain.
Therefore Dan killed two people.

Rather, White’s changed eating habits were presented primarily as part of a collection of behavioural changes indicating depression and psychological deterioration. There was also testimony touching on the possible relationship between diet and mood, which helped give later retellings of the case their extraordinary durability.

But the junk food was only part of a much larger psychiatric defence.

The actual argument was diminished capacity.

White’s lawyers maintained that his depression and mental condition had left him incapable of the deliberation, premeditation and malice required for murder.

The distinction matters.

Twinkies were evidence within the defence.

They were not, by themselves, the defence.

The Birth of the “Twinkie Defense”

Unfortunately for the complexities of jurisprudence, “diminished capacity caused by severe depression” does not make a particularly memorable headline.

“Twinkie defense” does.

The expression caught on.

It transformed an intricate—and controversial—psychiatric defence into an irresistible piece of popular culture.

Soon the story had mutated into something much simpler:

Dan White murdered two men and blamed it on junk food.

The phrase eventually escaped the White case altogether.

A “Twinkie defense” became shorthand for almost any apparently ridiculous attempt to explain or excuse someone’s behaviour.

There is an irony here.

The expression became so successful precisely because it distorted the legal argument it supposedly described.

But What About Premeditation?

This remains one of the most disturbing aspects of the case.

Consider White’s actions.

He took a loaded gun to City Hall.

He carried additional ammunition.

He avoided the normal public entrance and entered through a window.

He killed Moscone.

He then walked to another part of City Hall.

He approached Milk.

And he killed him too.

White’s defence nevertheless persuaded the jury that his mental condition prevented him from possessing the degree of deliberation and premeditation necessary for murder.

The prosecution strongly disputed this interpretation.

A prosecution psychiatrist who had interviewed White shortly after the killings testified that there was nothing in the interview suggesting a mental disorder, although the psychiatric evidence presented during the trial was extensive and conflicting.

The jury also heard White’s emotional recorded confession.

According to contemporary reporting, some jurors wept.

The trial had ceased to be simply an examination of physical evidence.

It had become an argument over the interior workings of Dan White’s mind.

The Verdict

On 21 May 1979, the jury returned its decision.

Not guilty of first-degree murder.

Not guilty of second-degree murder.

Instead, White was convicted on two counts of voluntary manslaughter.

The maximum sentence was seven years and eight months.

For many San Franciscans—particularly members of the gay community—the verdict was almost incomprehensible.

Harvey Milk had received death threats during his political career.

A man had entered City Hall carrying a firearm and ammunition, avoided the public entrance, shot the mayor, travelled through the building and then shot Milk.

And somehow the law had concluded that this was manslaughter rather than murder.

The anger was immediate.

White Night

Thousands gathered in the Castro and marched towards City Hall.

The demonstration became increasingly furious.

For many gay San Franciscans, the verdict represented considerably more than dissatisfaction with one criminal trial.

It touched years of accumulated anger about discrimination, police treatment, violence against gay people and a justice system many believed did not value gay lives equally.

Police cars were attacked and set alight.

Windows at City Hall were smashed.

Police and demonstrators fought.

The violence became known as the White Night riots.

But the confrontation did not end at City Hall.

Police subsequently moved into the Castro.

Officers entered gay establishments, damaged property and assaulted patrons and people in the streets.

Thus a trial already born from political assassination became entangled with another longstanding source of tension—the relationship between gay communities and police.

The night represented an extraordinary transformation.

Only six months earlier, after Milk and Moscone were murdered, thousands had walked through San Francisco in an overwhelmingly peaceful candlelight procession.

After the verdict, candles were replaced by flames.

Was Harvey Milk Killed Because He Was Gay?

This question requires care.

White and Milk were political opponents, and Milk had opposed White’s return to the Board of Supervisors.

The immediate circumstances of the killings centred heavily on White’s resignation, his failed attempt to regain his seat and his belief that political opponents had prevented Moscone from reappointing him.

It is therefore too simplistic to describe Milk’s assassination solely as a straightforward anti-gay hate crime.

Yet homosexuality cannot simply be removed from the historical context either.

Milk was not merely another supervisor.

He was perhaps the most visible openly gay politician in America.

White had opposed the city’s gay-rights ordinance and had expressed socially conservative views about homosexuality.

More importantly, the gay community’s reaction to White’s conviction reflected its broader historical experience.

Gay people knew what it meant for violence against them to be trivialised, ignored or inadequately punished.

Whatever combination of political resentment, psychological instability and personal grievance motivated Dan White, Harvey Milk’s death was inevitably experienced by gay people as the assassination of one of their own.

And that gave the verdict enormous symbolic power.

What Happened to the Diminished-Capacity Defence?

The controversy surrounding the White verdict contributed to a broader backlash against California’s diminished-capacity doctrine.

California subsequently abolished diminished capacity as a formal defence.

The law did not simply become “you can no longer use the Twinkie defense”; the legal changes were more substantial than the popular slogan suggests.

But the White case became one of the most notorious examples used in arguments that psychiatric evidence had allowed defendants to escape appropriate responsibility for deliberate acts.

In that sense, the trial had consequences far beyond Dan White himself.

White Leaves Prison

White was sentenced to seven years and eight months.

He did not serve anything approaching a lifetime sentence.

He was released in January 1984, after approximately five years in prison.

His release reopened wounds that had barely healed.

For many people in San Francisco, there was something almost grotesque about the arithmetic.

George Moscone was dead.

Harvey Milk was dead.

Dan White was free.

After parole in Southern California, White eventually returned to the San Francisco Bay Area.

On 21 October 1985, aged 39, Dan White died by suicide through carbon-monoxide poisoning in the garage of his home.

Seven years had not yet passed since the assassinations.

The Twinkie That Ate the Story

There is something almost appropriate about the fact that the Twinkie defense became a myth.

Harvey Milk understood better than most politicians that symbols have extraordinary power.

And the Twinkie became a symbol.

It symbolised a verdict many people could not understand.

It symbolised frustration with psychiatric defences.

And for many gay people it symbolised something darker—the suspicion that the justice system had somehow found a way to diminish the seriousness of Harvey Milk’s murder.

But reducing the trial to “Twinkies made him do it” actually hides the more interesting—and more troubling—questions.

How should mental illness affect criminal responsibility?

How can a jury determine whether someone truly premeditated an act?

How much weight should psychiatric testimony receive?

Can a person undertake a sequence of apparently deliberate actions while nevertheless lacking the mental capacity the law requires for murder?

And why did so many gay San Franciscans immediately believe that the verdict demonstrated something fundamentally unjust about the society in which they lived?

Those questions cannot be answered by a snack cake.

Harvey’s Victory

There is another reason the story should not end with Dan White.

White killed Harvey Milk.

He did not kill what Milk represented.

Milk had famously recorded messages to be played in the event of his assassination because he understood that his political visibility made him vulnerable.

His central political message was remarkably simple.

Gay people had to be visible.

They had to participate.

They had to vote.

They had to run for office.

They had to make it impossible for society to pretend they did not exist.

White’s bullets ended Milk’s life at 48.

But assassination transformed Milk from a San Francisco politician into an international symbol.

Decades later, Harvey Milk’s name appears on schools, buildings, streets and institutions. His life has inspired books, documentaries, an opera and the Academy Award-winning film Milk.

Dan White’s name survives too.

But largely because he killed Harvey Milk.

And because somebody mentioned a Twinkie.

Perhaps history delivered its own verdict after all.

Tim Alderman ©️2026

Sources and further reading

Contemporary reporting

Francis J. Moriarty, “Defense, State Rest in Murder Trial of Ex-Supervisor White,” The Washington Post, 11 May 1979.

Francis Moriarty, “White Is Convicted of Voluntary Manslaughter,” The Washington Post, 22 May 1979.

San Francisco Chronicle archival coverage of the Dan White verdict and White Night disturbances.

Nancy Skelton and Mark A. Stein, “S.F. Assassin Dan White Kills Himself,” Los Angeles Times, 22 October 1985.

Legal background

Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute, material on diminished capacity and the history of the “Twinkie defense.”

California statutory changes concerning diminished capacity and evidence of mental disorder in determining criminal intent.

Harvey Milk and gay history

Harvey Milk Foundation, biographical history of Harvey Milk.

Randy Shilts, The Mayor of Castro Street: The Life and Times of Harvey Milk.

Robert Epstein and Richard Schmiechen, The Times of Harvey Milk (1984), documentary film.

Historical accounts of the White Night riots and San Francisco gay politics during the 1970s.

For the myth itself

Carol Pogash, “Myth of the ‘Twinkie Defense’,” San Francisco Chronicle, 23 November 2003.

Contemporary and retrospective reporting on psychiatric testimony during People v. White.

One little historical irony particularly appeals to me: the Twinkie has achieved something Dan White never managed—it has survived for decades with its reputation largely intact. 😂

And I think the most important distinction in the piece is that we haven’t sanitised White’s defence merely because the popular version is wrong. The defence really did introduce his dramatic change to junk-food consumption as psychiatric evidence; it simply wasn’t “Twinkies caused the murders.” Contemporary reporting confirms that the defence was fundamentally trying to establish diminished capacity through depression and other evidence.

The manslaughter verdict on 21 May 1979 provoked an immediate march from the Castro toward City Hall and the violence remembered as White Night. White served about five years and died by suicide in October 1985.

Leave a Reply